Top Picks for Rye Whiskey

KOVAL Distillery Bottled In Bond Rye Whiskey
94 points
$50
Bread pudding made with Rye bread; not quite what you expected but so so tasty.
Awards: 2022 Top 2 Rye Whiskey
Jefferson’s Ocean Aged At Sea Voyage 26 Rye Whiskey
94 points
$79
A layered and delicious Rye that will benefit from more time in barrel.
Awards: 2022 Top 2 Rye Whiskey
Knob Creek 10 Year Old Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey
93 points
$69
A beautiful and powerful Rye with enough oak and age to round out the spices and have everything in balance as well as belie the ABV; a sipper that will make a great Old Fashioned or pair with a medium-bodied spicy Nicaraguan cigar.
Mayor Pingree 6 Year Aged Green Label Small Batch Cask Strength Rye Whiskey
93 points
$240
This is quite special with loads of cinnamon, pepper, and black chocolate; add a few drops of water to watch it open up.
Knob Creek 7 Year Old Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey
93 points
$36
A benchmark Rye Whiskey with just enough age and barrel influence to pull everything together; would make a truly high class Manhattan.
KO Distilling 4 Year Old Distiller’s Reserve Bottled-In-Bond Rye Whiskey
93 points
$74
Snacking on Rye bread and butter while walking through an herb garden.
Lasso Motel 10 Year Old Single Barrel Cask Strength Rye Whiskey
92 points
$89
Happiness is Rye Whiskey with age; this just really hits the mark and scratches an itch,and a couple drops of water really help pull complexity out of this spirit.
Switchgrass Spirits Bottled-In-Bond Rye Whiskey
92 points
$54
A spicy banana bread loaded with extra nuts; interesting and delicious.
Thresh & Winnow 10 Year Old Single Cask Rye Whiskey
92 points
$98
Really pops with the earthy flavors of the rye and then is nicely highlighted with pepper spice, light herbs, and barrel vanilla and baking spices.
Pendleton 1910 12 Year Old Canadian Rye Whisky
92 points
$44
This is a beautiful Rye Whiskey that can be enjoyed neat but has the spicy sweet complexity to play in Tiki cocktails.