From The Archive

This review was done in 2016. We can no longer certify the quality level indicated below without reviewing a current market sample.


Please note that it is a review for an older vintage of this wine brand and may taste vastly different than the description indicates. If you cannot find a review of a more current vintage, it is because the producer has not sent us samples for review within the last 3 or 4 years.

Submit Your Brand

If you are the brand owner or marketer for this product, please resubmit it for a current BevTest review by registering it at:

https://bevtest.com/get-reviewed/

If you have any additional questions regarding the submission process, please contact us at support@bevtest.com.
Expand Collapse

Their Portfolio

BR • 6 Degrees Cellars 2018 Rose, Pinot Noir, California 12.5% (USA) $13.00. - Bronze Medal
88 • Carmenet 2017 Red Blend, California 13.5% (USA) $13.00.
89 • Carmenet 2020 Merlot, California 12.5% (USA) $16.00.
87 • Carmenet 2021 Reserve Buttery, Chardonnay, Lodi 13.5% (USA) $13.00.
93 • Carmenet 2021 Chardonnay, California 12.5% (USA) $13.00.
86 • Longevity 2021 Debra’s Cuvee Rose, Pinot Noir, California 12% (USA) $16.00.
89 • Longevity 2018 Cabernet Sauvignon, California 13.5% (USA) $16.00.
86 • Longevity 2019 Chardonnay, Livermore Valley 13.5% (USA) $16.00.
87 • Longevity 2021 Debra’s Cuvée Rosé, Pinot Noir, California 12% (USA) $16.00.
87 • Montpellier 2021 Chardonnay, Napa Valley 12.5% (USA) $7.00.
88 • PINO Cellars 2022 Rosé, Pinot Noir, California 13.5% (USA) $15.00.
85 • Rare Earth 2021 Pinot Grigio, California 12.5% (USA) $14.00.
87 • Rosenblum NV Vinter’s Cuvee XXXX, Zinfandel, Lodi 13.9% (USA) $13.00.
85 • Shaw Organic 2021 Rosé, California 11.5% (USA) $8.00.
BR • Shaw Organic 2020 Red Blend, California 13% (USA) $8.00. - Bronze Medal
86 • Shaw Organic 2020 Cabernet Sauvignon, California 12% (USA) $8.00.
86 • Shaw Organic 2021 Chardonnay, California 12.5% (USA) $10.00.
85 • Shaw Organic 2022 Pinot Grigio, California 12.5% (USA) $10.00.
88 • Shaw Organic 2021 Rosé, California 11.5% (USA) $10.00.
BR • Tropic Mist NV Mango Strawberry Moscato, California 5.5% (USA) $11.00. - Bronze Medal
BR • Tropic Mist NV Blackberry Merlot, California 5.5% (USA) $11.00. - Bronze Medal
BR • Tropic Mist NV Exotic Fruits White Zinfandel, California 5.5% (USA) $11.00. - Bronze Medal
BR • Tropic Mist NV Raspberry Pink Moscato, California 5.5% (USA) $11.00. - Bronze Medal
93 • Villa Roya 2018 Generación De Pasión, Grenache, Calatayud 14.5% (Spain) $16.00.

Archive Review

Rutherford Vintners
2013 Malbec, Napa Valley
Gold Medal
Exceptional
Category: Malbec
Tasted In: 2016
Country: USA
Alcohol: 13.8%

Top Rated for
Malbec

AvinoDos 2017 Malbec, Oak Knoll District, Napa Valley
96 POINTS
AvinoDos 2017 Malbec, Oak Knoll District, Napa Valley
14.5% $42.00.
USA
Pampa 2022 Estate, Malbec, Mendoza
94 POINTS
Pampa 2022 Estate, Malbec, Mendoza
12% $9.00.
Argentina
Gordon Estate 2021 Reserve, Malbec, Columbia Valley
93 POINTS
Gordon Estate 2021 Reserve, Malbec, Columbia Valley
15% $35.00.
USA
Monte De Oro 2017 Vineyard Reserve, Malbec, Temecula Valley
93 POINTS
Monte De Oro 2017 Vineyard Reserve, Malbec, Temecula Valley
13.4% $90.00.
USA
AvinoDos 2018 Malbec, Oak Knoll District, Napa Valley
93 POINTS
AvinoDos 2018 Malbec, Oak Knoll District, Napa Valley
14.5% $42.00.
USA
Pampa 2019 Family Reserve, Malbec, Mendoza
93 POINTS
Pampa 2019 Family Reserve, Malbec, Mendoza
14.5% $29.00.
Argentina
Proverbial 2016 Malbec, Alexander Valley
93 POINTS
Proverbial 2016 Malbec, Alexander Valley
14% $16.00.
USA
Proverbial 2017 Malbec, Alexander Valley
93 POINTS
Proverbial 2017 Malbec, Alexander Valley
14% $16.00.
USA
Malbicho 2021 Malbec, Mendoza
93 POINTS
Malbicho 2021 Malbec, Mendoza
14.2% $10.00.
Argentina
High Lonesome Vineyard 2019 Emily
92 POINTS
High Lonesome Vineyard 2019 Emily's, Malbec, Cochise County, Arizona
13.3% $47.00.
USA
Biltmore Estate 2020 Limited Release, Malbec, American
92 POINTS
Biltmore Estate 2020 Limited Release, Malbec, American
13.9% $30.00.
USA
AvinoDos 2017 Two Barrel Reserve, Malbec, Oak Knoll District, Napa Valley
92 POINTS
AvinoDos 2017 Two Barrel Reserve, Malbec, Oak Knoll District, Napa Valley
14.5% $52.00.
USA
Alamos 2018 Seleccion, Malbec, Mendoza
92 POINTS
Alamos 2018 Seleccion, Malbec, Mendoza
13% $20.00.
Argentina

Best Buys for
Malbec

Pampa 2022 Estate, Malbec, Mendoza
94 POINTS
Pampa 2022 Estate, Malbec, Mendoza
12% $9.00.
Argentina
Proverbial 2016 Malbec, Alexander Valley
93 POINTS
Proverbial 2016 Malbec, Alexander Valley
14% $16.00.
USA
Proverbial 2017 Malbec, Alexander Valley
93 POINTS
Proverbial 2017 Malbec, Alexander Valley
14% $16.00.
USA
Malbicho 2021 Malbec, Mendoza
93 POINTS
Malbicho 2021 Malbec, Mendoza
14.2% $10.00.
Argentina
Alamos 2018 Seleccion, Malbec, Mendoza
92 POINTS
Alamos 2018 Seleccion, Malbec, Mendoza
13% $20.00.
Argentina
Kirkland Signature 2020 Malbec, Mendoza
92 POINTS
Kirkland Signature 2020 Malbec, Mendoza
14% $6.00.
Argentina
Santa Ana Homage 2022 Malbec, Mendoza
91 POINTS
Santa Ana Homage 2022 Malbec, Mendoza
12% $6.00.
Argentina
Alamos 2021 Malbec, Mendoza
90 POINTS
Alamos 2021 Malbec, Mendoza
13.5% $13.00.
Argentina
Alamos 2022 Malbec, Mendoza
90 POINTS
Alamos 2022 Malbec, Mendoza
13.5% $13.00.
Argentina
Eccentric 2022 Malbec, Mendoza
90 POINTS
Eccentric 2022 Malbec, Mendoza
13.5% $10.00.
Argentina
Don Rodolfo 2022 Malbec, Mendoza
89 POINTS
Don Rodolfo 2022 Malbec, Mendoza
14.5% $12.00.
Argentina
Alamos 2020 Malbec, Mendoza
89 POINTS
Alamos 2020 Malbec, Mendoza
13.5% $13.00.
Argentina
Pampa 2024 Estate, Malbec, Mendoza
88 POINTS
Pampa 2024 Estate, Malbec, Mendoza
13.5% $12.00.
Argentina
Kirkland Signature 2022 Malbec, Mendoza
88 POINTS
Kirkland Signature 2022 Malbec, Mendoza
14% $6.00.
Argentina
TOP RATED FOR CATEGORY BEST BUYS FOR CATEGORY

Rutherford Vintners 2013 Malbec, Napa Valley rating was calculated by to be 93 points out of 100 on 1/27/2016. Please note that MSRP may have changed since the date of our review.