Full Review

O’Reilly’s
Buy It Now

O’Reilly’s
Peanut Butter Country Cream Liqueur

Category: Cream Liqueur

Date Tasted:
Country: Ireland
Alcohol: 13.9%
86 Points
Silver Medal
Highly Recommended
$12
Best Buy

O’Reilly’s
Peanut Butter Country Cream Liqueur

Category: Cream Liqueur

Date Tasted:
Country: Ireland
Alcohol: 13.9%
Golden green color. Aromas and flavors of nutella and marshmallow fluff, peanut butter, saltine crackers, and vanilla cream with a creamy, moderately sweet full body and a tingling, intriguing, medium-length finish that exhibits notes of peanut butter nougat, honey, and hazel nut. Peanut butter marshmallow sandwich shots or frozen cocktails all day.

Tasting Info

Spirits Glass Style: Fruity
Aroma Aroma: nutella and marshmallow fluff, peanut butter, saltine crackers, and vanilla cream
Taste Flavor: Same as aromas with notes of peanut butter nougat, honey, and hazel nut
Smoothness Smoothness: Tingling
Finish Finish: Normal
Enjoy Enjoy: neat
Bottom Line Bottom Line: Peanut butter marshmallow sandwich shots or frozen cocktails all day.
Expand Collapse

The Producer or Importer

Prestige Beverage Group

The Producer or Importer
2300 Pilot Knob Road
Mendota Heights, MN 55120
USA
1 651-649-5823
Expand Collapse

Their Portfolio

85 • Barbayanni Ouzo 43% (Greece) $19.00.
91 • Caruva Horchata Cream Liqueur 12.5% (USA) $13.00.
92 • Eis Minze Peppermint Schnapps 50% (USA) $12.00.
87 • Grey Coast Irish Whiskey 40% (Ireland) $36.00.
92 • Henry’s Fork Organic Vodka 40% (USA) $22.00.
92 • Il Tramonto Limoncello 30% (Italy) $19.00.
BR • Joia Spirit Sparkling Cosmopolitan 7% (USA) $.00. - Bronze Medal
85 • Joia Spirit Sparkling Greyhound 6% (USA) $.00.
87 • Joia Spirit Paloma 6% (USA) $.00.
BR • Joia Spirit Margarita 6% (USA) $.00. - Bronze Medal
89 • Makaio Coffee Liqueur 21% (USA) $12.00.
86 • O’Reilly’s Peanut Butter Country Cream Liqueur 13.9% (Ireland) $12.00.
90 • O’Reilly’s Salted Caramel Country Cream Liqueur 13.9% (Ireland) $12.00.
89 • Ricura Horchata Cream Liqueur 12.5% (USA) $19.00.
88 • Risata NV Peach Flavored Semi-Sweet White Blend, Italy 5.5% (Italy) $12.00.
92 • Risata NV Blueberry Flavored Semi-Sweet Red Blend, Italy 6% (Italy) $12.00.
88 • Risata NV Estate Grown, Prosecco DOC 11% (Italy) $15.00.
88 • Risata NV Moscato d’Asti DOCG 5.5% (Italy) $12.00.
91 • Sheelin White Chocolate Cream Liqueur 13.9% (Ireland) $10.00.
89 • Sheelin Irish Cream Liqueur 13.9% (Ireland) $10.00.
91 • Tullibardine 12 Year Old Double Wood Single Malt Scotch Whisky 40% (Scotland) $49.00.
92 • Watkins Apple Cinnamon Bourbon Whiskey with Natural Flavors 35% (USA) $24.00.
87 • Watkins Spiced Orange Bourbon Whiskey with Natural Flavors 35% (USA) $24.00.
87 • Windsor Canadian Blended Canadian Whisky 40% (Canada) $12.00.
85 • Windsor Canadian Black Cherry Flavored Canadian Whiskey 35% (Canada) $12.00.
85 • Windsor Canadian Apple Flavored Canadian Whiskey 35% (Canada) $12.00.
Expand Collapse

Cream Liqueur

Spirits Glass Cream.jpg
Serve in a Rocks Glass
About
Cream Liqueur
Cream Liqueur, quite simply is a liqueur that has dairy cream added to a liquor. The most famous examples come from Ireland; they have a base of Irish whiskey; there are also version from Scotland, Canada, the US and several other countries.

Most of these cream liqueurs are in the 14% to 17% alcoholic range and are medium-sweet with flavors such as nougat, praline and chocolate. Most are served over the rocks. The category took off in the 1970s and although not as wildly popular today, it has remained strong.

Top Rated for
Cream Liqueur

Ole Smoky Banana Pudding Cream Moonshine
96 POINTS
Ole Smoky Banana Pudding Cream Moonshine
17.5% $26.00.
USA
Evan Williams Egg Nog Cream Liqueur
94 POINTS
Evan Williams Egg Nog Cream Liqueur
15% $10.00.
USA
Forty Creek Butter Tart Cream Liqueur
93 POINTS
Forty Creek Butter Tart Cream Liqueur
15% $26.00.
Canada
Jackson Morgan Southern Cream Spiced Pumpkin Roll Cream Liqueur
93 POINTS
Jackson Morgan Southern Cream Spiced Pumpkin Roll Cream Liqueur
15% $22.00.
USA
Pennsylvania Dutch American Bourbon Cream Liqueur
93 POINTS
Pennsylvania Dutch American Bourbon Cream Liqueur
12.5% $16.00.
USA
Pennsylvania Dutch Lemon Cream Pie Liqueur
93 POINTS
Pennsylvania Dutch Lemon Cream Pie Liqueur
12.5% $16.00.
USA
Pennsylvania Dutch Peaches & Cream Liqueur
93 POINTS
Pennsylvania Dutch Peaches & Cream Liqueur
12.5% $16.00.
USA
Pennsylvania Dutch Peppermint Bark Cream Liqueur
93 POINTS
Pennsylvania Dutch Peppermint Bark Cream Liqueur
12.5% $15.00.
USA
Pennsylvania Dutch Strawberries & Cream Liqueur
93 POINTS
Pennsylvania Dutch Strawberries & Cream Liqueur
12.5% $16.00.
USA
Member
93 POINTS
Member's Mark Egg Nog Cream Liqueur
15% $9.98.
USA
Pennsylvania Dutch Chocolate Cream Liqueur
92 POINTS
Pennsylvania Dutch Chocolate Cream Liqueur
12.5% $16.00.
USA
Pennsylvania Dutch Salted Caramel Cream Liqueur
92 POINTS
Pennsylvania Dutch Salted Caramel Cream Liqueur
12.5% $16.00.
USA
Kirkland Signature Irish Cream Liqueur
92 POINTS
Kirkland Signature Irish Cream Liqueur
17% $16.00.
Ireland
Sugarlands Distilling Co. Banana Pudding Appalachian Sippin
92 POINTS
Sugarlands Distilling Co. Banana Pudding Appalachian Sippin' Cream Liqueur
20% $25.00.
USA

Best Buys for
Cream Liqueur

Evan Williams Egg Nog Cream Liqueur
94 POINTS
Evan Williams Egg Nog Cream Liqueur
15% $10.00.
USA
Jackson Morgan Southern Cream Spiced Pumpkin Roll Cream Liqueur
93 POINTS
Jackson Morgan Southern Cream Spiced Pumpkin Roll Cream Liqueur
15% $22.00.
USA
Pennsylvania Dutch American Bourbon Cream Liqueur
93 POINTS
Pennsylvania Dutch American Bourbon Cream Liqueur
12.5% $16.00.
USA
Pennsylvania Dutch Lemon Cream Pie Liqueur
93 POINTS
Pennsylvania Dutch Lemon Cream Pie Liqueur
12.5% $16.00.
USA
Pennsylvania Dutch Peaches & Cream Liqueur
93 POINTS
Pennsylvania Dutch Peaches & Cream Liqueur
12.5% $16.00.
USA
Pennsylvania Dutch Peppermint Bark Cream Liqueur
93 POINTS
Pennsylvania Dutch Peppermint Bark Cream Liqueur
12.5% $15.00.
USA
Pennsylvania Dutch Strawberries & Cream Liqueur
93 POINTS
Pennsylvania Dutch Strawberries & Cream Liqueur
12.5% $16.00.
USA
Member
93 POINTS
Member's Mark Egg Nog Cream Liqueur
15% $9.98.
USA
Pennsylvania Dutch Chocolate Cream Liqueur
92 POINTS
Pennsylvania Dutch Chocolate Cream Liqueur
12.5% $16.00.
USA
Pennsylvania Dutch Salted Caramel Cream Liqueur
92 POINTS
Pennsylvania Dutch Salted Caramel Cream Liqueur
12.5% $16.00.
USA
Kirkland Signature Irish Cream Liqueur
92 POINTS
Kirkland Signature Irish Cream Liqueur
17% $16.00.
Ireland
Sugarlands Distilling Co. Banana Pudding Appalachian Sippin
92 POINTS
Sugarlands Distilling Co. Banana Pudding Appalachian Sippin' Cream Liqueur
20% $25.00.
USA
Caruva Horchata Cream Liqueur
91 POINTS
Caruva Horchata Cream Liqueur
12.5% $13.00.
USA
Sheelin White Chocolate Cream Liqueur
91 POINTS
Sheelin White Chocolate Cream Liqueur
13.9% $10.00.
Ireland
TOP RATED FOR CATEGORY BEST BUYS FOR CATEGORY

O’Reilly’s Peanut Butter Country Cream Liqueur rating was calculated by to be 86 points out of 100 on 8/29/2022. Please note that MSRP may have changed since the date of our review.